I fell in love with fitness in the ’90s, around the time when step aerobics and strength training for women became popular. As a teen, I began reading magazines like Muscle and Fitness, and I distinctly remember seeing ads for Met-Rx and eventually thermogenics like Ripped Fuel and Hydroxycut. In fact, since the mid ’90s, I have used many of the various popular thermogenics that have bombarded the market. I was not alone in how readily I consumed products that contained ephedra before it was pulled from the shelves and banned in 2003, “In 1999 some 12 million Americans consumed products containing ephedra” (Sports Illustrated). Since then, there have been dozens of cases of deaths linked with OTC (over-the-counter) supplements containing ephedra and DMAA. Here are three things you should know before you use any diet or fitness-related supplements:
- 1. Surprisingly, the supplier is held accountable, not the retailer. If something goes wrong with a supplement containing dangerous ingredients (such as ephedra or DMAA), the store it was sold in isn’t liable. As such, even a reputable chain could be selling something that is unsafe. “As the industry leader, GNC is at the center of a debate over the regulation of supplements and the vulnerability of consumers to potentially hazardous products” (NY Times).
- 2. Our government plays a relatively small role in ensuring that OTC supplements are safe for human consumption. “More than half of U.S. adults–or at least 114 million people–take dietary supplements, and the majority mistakenly believe that a government agency approves such products” (Chicago Tribune). Unlike pharmaceutical companies, “supplement makers are not required to prove that their products are safe and effective on humans. Nor do they have to get federal approval before selling their products.” The FDA is not spending the time or money it would take to ensure that the approximately 85,000 supplements available to consumers are safe. This would require first discovering and revealing the potentially hazardous drugs, and then proving them as such.
- 3. Individuals who use OTC supplements are at risk. Instead of the retailers and manufacturers suffering any financial consequences of selling products that are known to be unsafe, individual people are paying a price. In professional sports in particular, athletes are being fined or suspended from games from ingesting products that are being marketed as safe. Because there is not regulatory control on what is put into these supplements, I don’t think that the individual consumer should be held solely responsible for what is essentially a booming industry that big corporations are profiting from. I think that the accountability should lie with the large corporations. I agree wholeheartedly with NY State Senator Jeffrey D. Klein, who wants the sale of DMAA banned in his state. He asserts “You are in the business of selling ‘healthy’ products to consumers. I think you have a duty, before you put it on your shelves, to ensure that it’s not dangerous.”
Perhaps if more people were educated on the lack of regulation in the supplement industry, they would make better and safer choices when choosing what to take.
Battle lines solidify over bid to distinguish food, supplements, Julie Deardorff, Chicago Tribune, 9/9/11
Is the Seller to Blame?, N.Singer/P. Lattman, The New York Times, 3/15/13
What You Don’t Know Might Kill You, D. Epstein/G. Dohrmann, Sports Illustrated, 5/18/09